Friday, November 04, 2005

An Approximation of a Shadow of a Book Review

Oblivion

David Foster Wallace



DFW was my first introduction to contemporary literary fiction, so I owe him. His nigh-omniscient lexicon and quirky--dare I say, postmodern?--manipulation of literary styles and tropes endeared him to my wide-eyed late teen mind, and his themes on the isolation and emptiness of American life appealed to my loner tendencies. Having finished up his latest collection, I find that his stories which avoid resolution are the most disappointing, while those which aspire to halfway complete the narrative are far more appealing.



My favorites in this collection:

The Soul is Not a Smithy, a man reflects on a childhood incident when a substitute teacher suffers a mental breakdown in front of an elementary school class, intermingled with the narrator's description of the daydream which completely distracted him from the teacher's panicked mind.

Incarnations of Burned Children, a tragic, very short story that pierces straight to the heart.

Another Pioneer, a second-hand discussion of a story involving a preternaturally gifted child in a primitive village whose omniscience eventually destroys his home once he hits puberty.

Good Old Neon, an incredibly successful man, aghast at his own fraudulence yet also the (putative) cliches we repeat to ourselves to get through the day, describes his manipulative actions towards his fellow men which lead up to his suicide.

Here's a particularly striking stream-of-thought passage from his less successful story "Mister Squishy" about a focus-group facilitator who is trying to live with his awareness of his utter ordinariness:

Or maybe that even the mere possibility of expressing any of this childish heartbreak to someone else seemed impossible except in the context of the mystery of true marriage, meaning not just a ceremony and financial merger but a true communion of souls, and Schmidt now lately felt he was coming to understand why the Church all through his childhood catechism and pre-Con referred to it as the Holy Sacrament of Marriage, for it seemed every bit as miraculous and transrational and remote from the possibilities of actual lived life as the crucifixion and resurrection and transubstantiation did, which is to say it appeared not as a goal to expect ever to really reach or achieve but as a kind of navigational star, as in the sky, something high and untouchable and miraculously beautiful in the sort of distant way that reminded you always of how ordinary and unbeautiful and incapable of miracles you your own self were, which was another reason why Schmidt had stopped looking at the sky or going out at night or even usually ever opening the lightproof curtains of his condominium's picture window when he got home at night and instead sat with his satellite TV's channel-changer in his left hand switching rapidly from channel to channel out of fear that something better was going to come on suddenly on another of the cable provider's 220 regular and premium channels and that he was about to miss it, spending three nightly hours this way before it was time to stare with drumming heart at the telephone that wholly unbeknownst to her had Darlene Lilley's home number on Speed dial...
"Every effort was made to encourage the children at the public schools to "think for themselves." When they should have been whipped and taught Greek paradigms, they were set arguing about birth control and nationalization. Their crude little opinions were treated with respect. Preachers in the school chapel week after week entrusted the future to their hands. It is hardly surprising that they were Bolshevik at 18 and bored at 20."

-Evelyn Waugh, via Domenico Bettinelli

Thursday, November 03, 2005

All your Hip are Belong to Us

With leisure-time activities of consuming redefined as “rebellion,” two of late-capitalism’s great problems could easily be met: obsolescence found a new and more convincing language, and citizens could symbolically resolve the contradiction between their role as consumers and their role as producers. The countercult style has become a permanent fixture on the American scene, impervious to the angriest assaults of cultural and political cons., because it so conveniently and efficiently transforms the myriad petty tyrannies of econ. Life—all the complaints about conformity, oppression, bureaucracy, meaninglessness, and the disappearance of individualism that became virtually a natl obsession during the ‘50s—into rationales for consuming. No longer would Americans buy to fit in or to impress the Joneses, but to demonstrate that they were wise to the game, to express their revulstion with the artifice and conformity of consumerism. The enthusiastic discovery of the countercult by the branches of Amer. Business studied here marked the consolidation of a new species of hip consumerism, a cultural perpetual motion machine in which disgust with the falseness, shoddiness, and everyday oppressions of consumer society could be enlisted to drive the ever-accellerating wheels of consumption.”

-Thomas Frank, The Conquest of Cool

Monday, October 31, 2005

Something I'd like Arlen Specter to Say Unthinkingly:

"A woman's right to choose an abortion is as safe as the babe in her mother's womb."

He said what now?

Another admirer was Rosecrans Baldwin, who, along with Andrew Womack, founded The Morning News in Brooklyn in 1999.

"Paul and I met years ago when I wrote him an e-mail saying I liked an article he'd written," Mr. Baldwin said. "He wrote back saying he wanted to rape me. I replied with similar zest and our correspondence has continued similarly."


A Web Geek Takes off his Mask, NYTimes



Since when did rape humor become an ironic badge of hipness?

Sunday, October 30, 2005

Rene Descartes: Secret Jesuit Agent

According to the account given in his notebook - no copy of which exists, but which has been reconstructed using contemporary reports - Descartes formulated his philosophy of methodical doubt after a day in a stove-heated room and an ensuing night of extraordinary dreams. Grayling points out that the dreams were remarkably similar to those described in Rosicrucian texts. It is known that Descartes had many acquaintances among the Rosicrucians. Can we be sure that the intrepid rationalist was not a secret intellectual ally of these hermetic thinkers? Grayling thinks it unlikely, and makes the intriguing suggestion that Descartes may have been a spy working in the service of the Jesuits, who formed contacts with the Rosicrucians as part of an intelligence-gathering operation. In the nature of the case, there can be no proof, but it leaves the philosopher looking a surprisingly adventurous figure.

John Gray's Bookshop

Friday, October 28, 2005

An Excellent Summary of Christian Anthropology

Communion and Stewardship: Human Persons Created in the Image of God covers a vast range of subject matter in a succinct, surprisingly thorough manner. Psychology, bioethics, ecology, and evolutionary theory are all touched upon, though I particularly appreciated this passage on mind and body:

Two themes converge to shape the biblical perspective. In the first place, the whole of man is seen as created in the image of God. This perspective excludes interpretations which locate the imago Dei in one or another aspect of human nature (for example, his upright stature or his intellect) or in one of his qualities or functions (for example, his sexual nature or his domination of the earth). Avoiding both monism and dualism, the Bible presents a vision of the human being in which the spiritual is understood to be a dimension together with the physical, social and historical dimensions of man.



Contemporary academic approaches tend to either dismiss or praise Christian thought as dualistic, so it is nice to see a contrary voice, though I would much like to find some book expanding on this idea at length.

Also of note, an attention-grabbing speculation on the reconciliation of Darwinism with an Aristotelian philosophy of the forms:

In order to maintain the unity of body and soul clearly taught in revelation, the Magisterium adopted the definition of the human soul as forma substantialis (cf. Council of Vienne and the Fifth Lateran Council). Here the Magisterium relied on Thomistic anthropology which, drawing upon the philosophy of Aristotle, understands body and soul as the material and spiritual principles of a single human being. It may be noted that this account is not incompatible with present-day scientific insights. Modern physics has demonstrated that matter in its most elementary particles is purely potential and possesses no tendency toward organization. But the level of organization in the universe, which contains highly organized forms of living and non-living entities, implies the presence of some "information." This line of reasoning suggests a partial analogy between the Aristotelian concept of substantial form and the modern scientific notion of "information." Thus, for example, the DNA of the chromosomes contains the information necessary for matter to be organized according to what is typical of a certain species or individual. Analogically, the substantial form provides to prime matter the information it needs to be organized in a particular way. This analogy should be taken with due caution because metaphysical and spiritual concepts cannot be simply compared with material, biological data.


Stephen Barr recommended this paper in his essay on the Cardinal Shoenborn controversy, The Design of Evolution, as did Chancellor Fran Maier of the Archdiocese of Denver while introducing Richard Weikhart's presentation "From Darwin to Hitler."

Thursday, October 27, 2005

Novus Bloggus

Just noticed that Communio and Liberation has a weblog, Cahiers Peguy. It features an excellent short essay on Romeo and Juliet, among many other reflections.

Platonic Ethics doesn't end with the Euthyphro

I've noted my interest in the concept of theosis before , and it seems to have come up yet again. Right Reason takes Simon Blackburn to task for his overly-casual dismissal of Elizabeth Anscombe's ethical writings. Blackburn seems to follow the habit of so many readers of philosophy who treat the Euthyphro dialogue as Plato's last word on the relation between ethics and the divine, while ignoring his other commentaries. Frederick Copleston dilligently summarizes Platonic ethics in his History of Philosophy, a relevant section of which being this one:

Now, happiness must be attained by the pursuit of virtue, which means becoming as like to God as it is possible for man to become. We must become "like the divine so far as we can, and that again is to become righteous with the help of wisdom"(Theatetus 176 b 1-3) "The gods have a care of anyone whose desire is to become just and to be like God, as far as man can attain to the divine likeness, by the pursuit of virtue." (Rep. 613 a 7-b) In The Laws Plato declares that "God is the measure of all things, in a sense far higher than any man, as they say, can hope to be..."


Platonic divinization bears a not insignificant similarity to that concept of theosis especially prominent in Eastern Christianity, not to mention the Christian devotional practices encouraging the imitation of Christ. Indeed, the Catholic Catechism itself quotes St. Gregory of Nyssa: "the goal of the virtuous life is to become like God."(CCC para. 1803, orig. from De Virtutibus)

Most undergraduates never seem to get past the Euthyphro, which is terribly tragic. I do hope Simon Blackburn, an eminent philosopher himself, hasn't set a poor example for them.

Tuesday, October 25, 2005

"Some of the impurest books, that are extant in any language, are those written by the popish clergy on the subjects matrimony and divorces."
-William Blackstone, Commentaries


I don't doubt that this refers to ethical manuals instructing husbands and wives on their sexual responsibilities towards their spouse.

Monday, October 24, 2005

A Beg for Health Information

If anybody has information about Eosinophilic Esophagitis, its relation to chronic vomiting, chronic fatigue, and prednisone's effects thereon, and this information is not easily found in a lazy googling, please drop me a line.

And please throw me a pity party in the comments. Pity is my drug.

Thursday, October 20, 2005

A Comfort Amid Tribulations

Quanto plus afflictionis pro Christo in hoc saeculo, tanto plus gloriae cum Christo in futuro. Arundell
-St. Philip Howard, inscribed on the walls of the Tower of London, June 22, 1587

"The more suffering for Christ in this world, the greater the glory with Christ in the world to come."

Tuesday, October 18, 2005

The Managerial Class in the Catholic Parish

Yet as the professional middle class’s own self-understanding and self-representation has shifted over the last three decades from staid conformist to breezy rebel-part of the broader corporate cooptation of cultural rebellion that Thomas Frank has dubbed “the conquest of cool”-so the matrices of the laity have shifted from IBM, the Great Society, and the underground church to the Starbucks chain, the consumer dreamland of infinite choice and abundant lifestyles. Most of the sea changes that have transpired in American Catholicism since the midsixties-in liturgy, gender conventions, sexual mores, and priest-laity relations-have been variously initiated, scuttled, or corrupted among the college-trained, technoburban, consumerist enclaves of the flock, and it seems likely that these zones of professional and managerial culture will become only more powerful in the twenty-first century.

-Eugene McCarraher, "Smile When You Say Laity"

Monday, October 17, 2005

Love of the people is an aristocratic calling. The democrat only loves the people at election time.



So says Nicolás Gómez Dávila, apparently a philosopher of an anti-modern, or simply ultra-traditionalist bent. The linked site has many of his aphorisms. Many are very good, but a few are quite bad.

Against the Dictatorship of Polyannas

Amy Welborn declares herself a "Not-Nice Girl":

So most of the time, I am highly rational, understanding and compassionate. But the problem is that there are other times, when that whole shtick just runs out of steam, and more likely, runs right into the wall of people who don’t respond to rationality because they’re blinded by their egos, deafened by their obsession with power and incapable of engaging in rational discussions because they’re either too dumb or too imprisoned by mindless adherence to platitudes disguised as ideology.

Pride Goeth Before, And Cometh After, The Fall

This view [from the web] is spookily godlike. You can switch your gaze of a spot in the world from map to satellite to 3-D just by clicking. Recall the past? It's there. Or listen to the daily complaints and travails of almost anyone who blogs (and doesn't everyone?). I doubt angels have a better view of humanity. Kevin Kelly, We Are the Web



Via Nicholas Carr's brief essay, reminiscent of technoskeptic Cliff Stoll.

Friday, October 14, 2005

Thursday, October 13, 2005

The Modern State: Blind to the Good Life

What characterizes modern political thought is the rejection of the bona vita as a guide to political action. Men either lack such a thing as a natural vocation or at least they disagree about what such a vocation consists in. This makes it necessary to rethink politics, to begin with men as they are and to arrange things in order that those who are divided about the issue of what constitutes the good life will nevertheless live together in peace.


Philippe Beneton, The Languages of the Rights of Man


The essay doesn't present anything terribly new, but it is a quite concise political analysis of the modern predicament.

Also of interest:

True and False Tolerance, also by Beneton

Catholic Social Thought and the American Regime from Gary D. Glenn of the excellent Society of Catholic Social Scientists. Glenn attempts to revive the old interpretation that Locke's thought had some basis in Jesuit political philosophy--albeit only in part. He also notes that Richard Filmer, of Patriarcha fame, was an enemy of the early Jesuits' political philosophy.

Funniest Skull Ever

Monday, October 10, 2005

Aunt Margaret, RIP

She was a great woman, tough as nails and as fun as anyone on earth. The last of my family from the World War II generation.

Dona ei requiem, O domine.

Margaret E. Dwyer, 91, Kansas City, MO, passed away October 7, 2005. Mass of Christian Burial will be held at 10 a.m. Monday, October 10, 2005 at St. Peters Church, 6415 Holmes, Kansas City, MO 64131. Interment will be at Calvary Cemetery. Friends may call from 3-5 p.m. Sunday, October 9 at Muehlebach Funeral Home, 6800 Troost, Kansas City, MO where the rosary will be prayed at 4:30 p.m. Memorial contributions may be made to the St. Peters Church Legacy Fund or Catholic Charities, 1112 Broadway, Kansas City, MO 64105. Margaret was born July 1, 1914 in Kansas City, MO to William W. and Esther C. (Birmingham) Hale. She was a member of St. Peters Church and retired from the Kansas City Missouri School District after many years of service. Margaret was preceded in death by her brother, William J. Hale and her sister, Mary Bernice Jones. Survivors include her daughters, Margaret Ann Sears, Cincinnati, OH and Patricia Lee Scaglia, Kansas City, MO; grandchildren, John T. Benson, Jr., James P. Benson, Ann B. Shah, Phillip P. Scaglia, and Patricia M. Scaglia; great-grandchildren, Amanda Benson, Meghan Benson, Blake Benson, Amelia Shah, and Aidan Shah; sister-in-law, Mary Catherine Hale and nephews, Montgomery Bruce Jones, William J. Hale, Jr. and Bill Jones. (Arr; Muehlebach Funeral Home, 816-444-2060).

Saturday, October 08, 2005

“Two years ago, if somebody had said our soldiers would do these things to detainees and take pictures of it, I would have said that’s a lie,” sighed recently retired General Michael Marchand, who as assistant judge advocate general for the Army was responsible for reforming military training policy in the wake of Abu Ghraib. “What soldiers do, I’m not sure I can guess anymore.”

A sad commentary, evidence that there's many from Generation: Porn in Generation: Kill. From War Pornography, in an article not for the sensitive.



via Kevin Michael Grace

Friday, October 07, 2005

A Somewhat Anti-Catholic and Very Flaky Urban Legend is Loose

An email has been circulating recently referring to a newsletter we supposedly sent out this week titled "If Your Child is a Gothic, Reform Through the Lord". There has been no such letter either sent out by St. Mary's Cathedral or posted on our website. It appears that this is just another fictional email circulating on the web. For verification of the legitimacy of any email, visit http://www.snopes.com. Thank you for visiting our site!

Saint Mary's Cathedral, Colorado Springs


Here's the actual rumor:

If Your Child is a Gothic, Reform Through the Lord!

Listed below are some warning signs to indicate if your child may have gone astray from the Lord. Gothic (or goth) is a very obscure and often dangerous culture that young teenagers are prone to participating in.
The gothic culture leads young, susceptible minds into an imagined world of evil, darkness, and violence. Please seek immediate attention through counselling, prayer, and parental guidance to rid your child of Satan's temptations if five or more of the following are applicable to your child:

-Frequently wears black clothing.
-Wears band and/or rock t-shirts.
-Wears excessive black eye makeup, lipstick or nailpolish.
-Wears any odd, silver jewelry or symbols. Some of these include: reversed crosses, pentagrams, pentacles, ankhs or various other Satanic worshipping symbols.
-Shows an interest in piercings or tattoos.
-Listens to gothic or any other anti-social genres of music. (Marilyn Manson claims to be the anti-Christ, and publicly speaks against the Lord. Please discard any such albums IMMEDIATELY.)
-Associates with other people that dress, act or speak eccentrically.
-Shows a declining interest in wholesome activities, such as: the Bible, prayer, church or sports.
-Shows an increasing interest in death, vampires, magic, the occult, witchcraft or anything else that involves Satan.
-Takes drugs.
-Drinks alcohol.
-Is suicidal and/or depressed.
-Cuts, burns or partakes in any other method of self-mutilation. (This is a Satanic ritual that uses pain to detract from the light of God and His love. Please seek immediate attention for this at your local mental health center.)
-Complains of boredom.
-Sleeps too excessively or too little.
-Is excessively awake during the night.
-Dislikes sunlight or any other form of light. (This pertains to vampires promoting the idea that His light is of no use.)
-Demands an unusual amount of privacy.
-Spends large amounts of time alone.
-Requests time alone and quietness. (This is so that your child may speak to evil sprits through
meditation.)
-Insists on spending time with friends while unaccompanied by an adult.
-Disregards authority figures; teachers, priests, nuns and elders are but a few examples of this.
-Misbehaves at school.
-Misbehaves at home.
-Eats goth-related foods. Count Dracula cereal is an example of this.
-Drinks blood or expresses an interest in drinking blood. (Vampires believe this is how to attain Satan. This act is very
dangerous and should be stopped immediately.)
-Watches cable television or any other corrupted media sources. (Ask your local church for proper programs that your
child may watch.)
-Plays videos games that contains violence or are of a role-playing nature.
-Uses the internet excessively and frequently makes time for the computer.
-Makes Satanic symbols and/or violently shakes head to music.
-Dances to music in a provocative or sexual manner.
-Expresses an interest in sex.
-Masturbates
-Is homosexual and/or bisexual.
-Pursues dangerous cult religions. Such include: Satanism, Scientology, Philosophy, Paganism, Wicca, Hinduism and Buddhism.
-Wears pins, stickers or anything else that contains these various phrases: "I'm so gothic, I'm dead", "woe is me", "I'm a goth".
-Claims to be a goth.

If five or more of these apply to your child, please intervene immediately. The gothic culture is dangerous and Satan thrives within it. If any of these problems persist, enlist your child into your local mental health center.

~St. Mary's Catholic Church


I'd like to know who started this thing. Bishop Sheridan and Bishop Emeritus Hanifen were in the news around election time last year, but I don't think it's likely to be related to this silly thing.

Thursday, October 06, 2005

"I am Legion"

“I think God’s sense of economy is very different from our own - so different it’s scary. To him the plight of one vagrant is more important than all the money in the world. And He’ll plunder our treasure to save him.”
WaiterRant reflects on the Gethsemane exorcism and his own demons quite excellently.

via fellow Colorado blogger Christ-Haunted

A Vulgar Authorship Debate

"Who is Bacon?"

"Some chap who's supposed to have written Shakespeare's plays."

"Awfully decent of him."

"I think so."

"Of course, he may have owed Shakespeare some money."

"Well, there is that."

Via Tom's comments at Zadok the Roman, supposedly originally from Wodehouse.

I'll Never Grow Up! Not Me!

Robert McHenry at Tech Central Station has a piquant essay Yes, I'm Definitely Saying Something About Your Mother comparing the oft-demanded Public Sensitivity Tribute to old schoolyard fight rituals:

How many of you have ever been confronted with some variation of the challenge to which the title of this essay is the answer you never dared offer? It's a schoolyard kind of thing, a rite of passage of sorts, perhaps, but certainly a ritualistic performance involving several people. There's the challengee, of course -- you, if you're male and a little, shall we say, averse to rough play. You might be alone, but the odds are you have a couple of like-minded friends with you. Then there's the challenger. You know what he's like without my making you recall the details. Invariably he has some pals with him. This is invariable because what we have is a piece of street theater, and the star needs a sympathetic audience.

So Tough Guy poses to you the question that has no correct answer: "You sayin' something about my mother?" You've probably said nothing at all up to now, hoping to avoid trouble, and so you stammer out "No, no, of course not." [Cue the adrenalin: heartbeat up? Check. Breaths short and shallow? Check. That clammy feeling? Check.] To which the scripted reply is "You calling me a liar?" He advances, you retreat; he perhaps prods you with a forefinger. Despite the physical menace, though, he doesn't want to fight so much as simply to intimidate, and to elicit the moronic leers of his chums; you want only to wake from a nightmare.


via The Japery

Another Miniver Cheevy on the 'Net?

I'm pretty tired of rants against relativism, but this guy is rather endearing:

...There was so much I could say, but she would never hear it, so I saved my breath. And then it hit me--the ultimate fashion would be a t-shirt with "Truth's Beauty" written on it. And there was that girl back in NC. It would look good on her. And we would never sell the shirt, but only ever encourage people to make their own. It would be an open-source fashion project!!

Dante reserved a special place for buzz marketers in hell--they never stood up for the right nor the wrong, good nor bad, but only ever ran with the latest fad. And so it is that Dante had them running after a blank banner in a cirlce, while hornets bit them and worms sucked their blood, as when they were living, they stung others by blogging little cutesy-ttotsey falsehoods, all to suck their cash away, into the beltway.

But just as one cannot deconstruct the Great Books, but only oneself, reality cannot be hacked, but only one's private perception of it. For the truth shall prevail, and thus the buzzters and pomo-elite reality hackers slowly hack their very own souls with each lie they tell, hype, and promote, with each dollar they lust after, with each falsehood they broadcast, until they no longer no right from wrong, good from bad--until they no longer know Truth's Beauty.


I think I came across him before, when he was canvassing for volunteers to put together a Dante's Inferno video game. Quixotic, aesthetically wacky, but sincere.

Tuesday, October 04, 2005

Let's All Help the Cowboys (Sing the Blues)

By Waylon Jennings

Cowboys they are ladies men all right
They'll love 'em up and talk 'em up all night
But they're lonely when there's nothing else to do
And that's what makes the cowboys sing the blues
He does a little Shakespeare and he sings
He plays the mandolin and other things
He looks for love beauty and IQ
And that's what makes the cowboy sing the blues

Cowboys have to fall in love get hurt and all that bit
Let their hearts hang out so they can write you all a hit
So ladies if they ask you don't refuse
Let's all help the cowboys sing the blues

Cowboys they don't ever understand
This thing between a woman and a man
Until they find the one they always lose
That's what makes the cowboys sing the blues
A cowboy takes his lonely pen in hand
And tries to make somebody understand
But she has ears to hear a different tune
And that's what makes the cowboy sing the blues

Thursday, September 29, 2005

Another Lament...

A Lament for Our Lady's Shrine at Walsingham

"In the wrackes of Walsingam
Whom should I chuse
But the Queene of Walsingam
To be guide to my muse?

Then thou Prince of Walsingam
Grant me to frame
Bitter plaintes to rewe thy wronge
Bitter wo for thy name.

Bitter was it oh to see
The seely sheepe
Murdered by the raveninge wolves
While the sheephards did sleep.

Bitter was it oh to vewe
The sacred vyne
While the gardiners plaied all close
Rooted up by the swine.

Bitter, bitter oh to behould
The grasse to growe
Where the walls of Walsingam
So stately did shewe.

Such were the works of Walsingam
While shee did stand
Such are the wrackes as now do shewe
Of that so holy land.

Levell levell with the ground
The towres doe lye
Which with their golden, glitteringe tops
Pearsed once to the skye.

Where weare gates no gates are nowe,
The waies unknowen,
Where the press of peares did passe
While her fame far was blowen.

Oules do scrike where the sweetest himnes
Lately weer songe,
Toades and serpents hold their dennes
Wher the palmers did thronge.

Weepe, weepe O Walsingam,
Whose dayes are nightes,
Blessings turned to blasphemies,
Holy deeds to dispites.

Sinne is wher our Ladie sate,
Heaven turned is to hell,
Satham sittes wher our Lord did swaye,
Walsingam, oh farewell ! "

-Anon. 16th Century Recusant

This poem was published in Eamon Duffy's The Stripping of the Altars, an excellent account of the English Reformation

Sensitivity Vigilante objects to 'Philistine'

The End of Satire is at hand. A blog commentor at Matthew Lickona's Godsbody objects to 'philistine', claiming it is a racial slur. See the comments.

A Lamentation for Constantinople

The Last Mass in Hagia Sophia

Anonymous Song of Lamentation
for the Fall of Constantinople in 1453.
Translated by Richard Stoneman


God rings the bells, earth rings the bells, the sky itself is ringing,
The Holy Wisdom, the great church, is ringing out the message,
Four hundred sounding boards sound out, and two and sixty bells,
For every bell there is a priest, for every priest a deacon.
To the left the emperor is singing, to the right the patriarch,
And all the columns tremble with the thunder of the chant.
And as the emperor began the hymns to the Cherubim,
A voice came down to them from the sky, from the archangel’s mouth:
Cease the Cherubic hymn, and let the sacred objects bow;
Priests, take the holy things away, extinguish all the candles:
God’s Will has made our city now into a Turkish city.
But send a message to the West, and let them send three ships:
The first to take the cross, the second to remove the Gospel,
The third, the finest shall rescue for us our holy altar.
Lest it all to those dogs, and they defile it and dishonour it.
The Holy Virgin was distressed, the very icons wept.
Be calm, beloved lady, be calm and do not weep for them.
Though years, though centuries shall pass, they shall be yours again.

via Basia Me, Catholica Sum

Tuesday, September 27, 2005

Quomodo Sola Sedet Civitas

Two of the people in my favorite links, Askel5 and Romulus, are residents of New Orleans, and I would be remiss were I to neglect recording their own comments on their home city's woeful situation.

Askel5:
women are in short supply in the city

Romulus:
Especially the right kind of woman. Had a tense conversation yesterday with one of the wrong kind. She was touring my neighborhood yesterday as part of an out of town fire department team, surveying homes "to see when people can be allowed back". That pissed me off, and these state-funded jobsworths had to listen politely while I informed them that at least someone is on to the use of this disaster to engineer a massive state power grab, and how sorry I am that they lend themselves to these abuses cloaked as helping people, that all we need is for the power to come on, and that in a free country people are allowed to assess danger for themselves

[...]

To continue the power-grab riff: the state is peddling hysteria every chance it gets. I stopped by Baptist Hospital also, to see if I could locate my father's cardiologist. The entire multi-block region was cordoned off. The blue-clad rent-a-cop (festooned with cool cop gear, including embroidered patch with the word "International" on it. "Huh?") was of course creepily friendly and polite, but selling his story that the area was so dangerous that "we shouldn't even be out here talking". He was all set up with trailer (generator humming away), sun shaded area, crates of Gatorade and canned food, and the Offlical Line: the air inside the medical office building is so toxic even Federal Professionals don't dare enter (being sold on the story themselves, I don't doubt it), because Mold Kills, you know; that we're surrounded by Deadly Sewer Water (Ed Norton I guess flirted with dangers Ralph and Alice Cramden never suspected), and the entire zone is a toxic biohazard. "You don't really believe that, do you?" was my response; I do believe I actually scored a hit with that, as he admitted that if he feared for his life he probably wouldn't be there either. As I drove off, my last words to him were: "I hope you get to go home real soon."

Source


Romulus records his adventures in evading patrolling helicopters here. He has also resolved that come the next checkpoint, upon being asked if he has any weapons he will reply: "Why, do you think I need one?"

Friday, September 23, 2005

This Guy Deserves a Blog Post

...not to mention a little justice.

The trial of Zhang Shengqi and two other members of the clandestine Catholic Church opened on 16 March 2004 behind closed doors. All three are accused of "divulging state secrets".

Liu Fenggang is accused of carrying out research for a report exposing Chinese government repression of the clandestine Catholic Church. Xu Yonghai is on trial for having printed the report and Zhang Shengqi for undertaking to post it on the Internet and to send it electronically to organisations abroad.


Reporters Without Borders

Monday, September 19, 2005

LifeTeen under Attack

The Rocky, in an article soon to be lost to its unarchived memory hole, discusses a controversy about the Life Teen program for Catholic youth at Light of the World parish.

The article "Doubts aired about Life Teen program" concentrates on concerns about the sexual abuse allegation that has been leveled at the program's Phoenix-based founder, and the money apparently paid to LifeTeen, Inc. for the dubious privilege of running the program.

The article contains something that's news to me:

Life Teen listed $8.4 million in assets in 2003, the most recent year for which records were available.


That's a lot of money.

I despise LifeTeen for its uncritical and blatant pandering to youth culture and the program's insipid rock "Praise" music, the performance of which almost always overshadows the liturgy.

Though aware of the charge against its creator, I hadn't made much of it. I don't know if the concerns about the program's creator are stand-ins for objections to the LifeTeen program itself.

An Anthropological Oddity

The idea of God isn't a supernatural idea. If the idea of God were supernatural, then religion would be true. The idea of God, the idea, the representation of something supernatural is not itself supernatural. If it were, then we [anthropologists] would be out of business.

Dan Sperber


This guy seems to have become stuck while jumping between his fishbowl of human experience and the "outside" scientific perspective. Or, rather, something has stayed stuck to him.

Friday, September 16, 2005

Factchecker in Chapter 9, Please

Apparently Kurt Vonnegut has a new best-selling book out, "A Man without a Country." Looking through the book on Amazon, I find it repeats the same error pointed out here before, where Vonnegut attributes Jesus' words to Confucius, explicitly denying Jesus said them.

To repeat myself: Now thanks to Mr. Vonnegut we have yet another error half-educated people will repeat as Gospel truth.

And then there is California...

Making legislative sausage - the arm-twisting, compromising, backroom-deal-making, back-stabbing - is not for the faint of heart. A particularly nasty incident has been reported in the Sacramento Bee. Earlier this month the state Senate's dictatorial Appropriations Committee chairwoman, Democrat Carole Migden of San Francisco, marched over to the Assembly floor to watch a vote on her bill to add new regulatory requirements for cosmetic manufacturers.

With the bill one vote shy of passage, she went to Republican Guy Houston's desk and pushed the "yes" button so that a vote would be electronically recorded. The normally mild-mannered Assemblyman Bob Huff, the Diamond Bar Republican who sits next to Houston, saw this and had to push Migden's arm away, then undo the vote. Huff told me that Migden's excuse - that she thought the desk was a Democrat's - is bogus. She has a reputation for doing this, he said, and even if it had been a Democrat's desk, a senator has no right to cast a vote in the Assembly chambers.

The ugly truth about Sacramento

Tuesday, September 13, 2005

Tommy Aquinas on Chance, as applied to Darwinism

I've long been noting the existential despair lurking behind certain proponents of neo-Darwinism. I had one anthropology professor who was inclined to share his despair with the whole lecture hall. He would basically repeat a less poetic version of MacBeth's lament: tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing, etc.

Curiously enough, the hard Darwinian commitment to random mutation doesn't translate into a willingness to consider a irrationalist epistemology that adapts by means of random ideas. I once tried to glean Daniel Dennett's opinion on the matter when he lectured on meme theory. Meme theory, with its almost pathological language of infection, dispersion, and so forth, seems to me to be most amenable to irrationalism, but Dennett simply gave the gruff, curt reply that such application was an abuse of the theory.

Anyway, somebody has put together a nice little Thomistic treatise on chance and design in evolutionary philosophy and the philosophy of its major opponents. See A Designer Universe: Chance, Design, and Cosmic Order

Against Education

The Japery has a roundup of some articles reflecting on the ideology of Education. Good old Ivan "Deschooling Society" Illich makes a showing, of course.

Particularly striking is one comment from this piece stating:

Comenius is the patron Saint of those who would transform creation into a classroom and humanity into students. Comenius legacy is the dis-enchantment of the world. The path of Comenius leads us, as Illich has pointed out, to the terrors of a world understood as a yet another device for the use of education and not as a good creation of a creators imaginative and windy engagement with chaos. Creation as a technique or method or as raw material to be used to manufacture the new humanity is the alchemical black magic of such noxious views as Skinnerian behaviourism or the re-education camps of the cultural revolution or even more insidious the liberal Christian view that salvation is won through proper schooling.


Secularization is possibly at work even in the putatively most backward arena of biology, "Creation Science."

An interesting passage from an interview with Illich:
I remember on my next trip to New York going to Princeton to see Jacques Maritain, the philosopher, who was then living there. We had met up in Rome in a seminar and he had become a dear friend and advisor. His imaginative Thomism meant a lot to me. He was then an old man with a face, as Ann Freemantle once said, cut from a stained glass window in Chartres. In 1957, I was now sitting there with him again. He had a teacup in his hand and was shaking when I talked to him about the question which bothered me, that in all his philosophy I didn't find any access to the concept of planning. He asked me if this was an English word for accounting, and I told him no ... if it was for engineering, and I said no ... and then at a certain moment he said to me, "Ah! Je comprends, mon cher ami, maintenant je comprends." Now I finally understand. "C'est une nouvelle espèce du pêche de presomption." Planning is a new variety of the sin of pride.


These pieces also bring to mind a short critique of John Henry Cardinal Newman's philosophy of education, Knowledge for the Sake of Knowledge

Friday, September 09, 2005

The New Edition of The New Pantagruel is out.

Thursday, September 08, 2005

The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927

The flood brought another clever political manipulator to office: legendary Louisiana Gov. Huey Long. Long's populist mandate arose in great measure as a reaction to a huge fissure that the flood created in New Orleans society. As the flood waters started approaching New Orleans, the close-knit cabal of New Orleans bankers who ran Louisiana from their exclusive krewes and clubs decided they were going to save their own skins by dynamiting a levee about 10 miles from the city. They were powerful enough that they didn't even need to do it under the cover of night -- they got the governor to sign an order making the operation legal.

James Carville, Swamp Fever, April 7, 1997


I hadn't heard about this until the catastrophe last week. The exposure of the failures of a system based on plutocratic self-interest, and the rise of a populist politics, all precipitated by a great disaster. Will be on the lookout for any signs of historical recapitulation.


One possible correction to the essay: Carville seems to indicate that Shelby Foote was actually a relative of Walker Percy. I don't think this was the case. As far as I know, he was just a semi-adopted family friend

Wednesday, September 07, 2005

Yuppies in the Sky

Sung to the tune of Ghost Riders in the Sky

One night as I was walking down Columbus Avenue
The sushi bars were shuttered, and the dark cantina too
I stood there in the darkness as an empty cab rolled by
When all at once I heard the sound of yuppies in the sky

The herd came down Columbus for as far as I could see
The men were wearing polo and the women wore esprit
Each yuppie had a Walkman, and as each one passed me by
I saw their sad expressions and I heard their mournful cry

Condos for sale, Condos to buy, Oh Yuppies in the sky
Condos for sale, Condos to buy, Oh Yuppies in the sky

Written by Tom Paxton

Tuesday, September 06, 2005

The Storm had a Say, Too.

Mere Comments voices a necessary note against that bad old technotriumphalism in light of the Katrina blame game:

What I find interesting, though, has been the instant, reflexive resort to the belief, and accusation, that SOMEONE IS TO BLAME for this. Someone can and must be held accountable for this vast calamity. This, it seems to me, is a powerful confirmation of something that I have argued in the pages of Touchstone before: that the increase in our mastery over the physical terms of our existence will not make us happier or more content, and may even lead to chronic political and social instability and unease, precisely because of the unsatisfiable expectations it generates.

Friday, September 02, 2005

"It is Sad to Contemplate How Few Politicians are Hanged."

Via Crooks and Liars, a journalist doing his job confronts a Louisiana Senator who is on Public Speaking autopilot--speaking as though she hadn't just lost a few thousand of her people and was simply on another campaign stop:

LANDRIEU: Thank President Clinton and former President Bush for their strong statements of support and comfort today. I thank all the leaders that are coming to Louisiana and Mississippi and Alabama. We are grateful for the military assets that are being brought to bear. I want to thank Senator Frist and Senator Reid for their extraordinary efforts--Anderson, tonight, I don't know if you've heard -- maybe you all have announced it -- but Congress is going to an unprecedented session to pass a $10 billion supplemental bill tonight to keep FEMA and the Red Cross up and operating.

COOPER: Excuse me, Senator, I'm sorry for interrupting. I haven't heard that, because, for the last four days, I've been seeing dead bodies in the streets here in Mississippi. And to listen to politicians thanking each other and complimenting each other, you know, I got to tell you, there are a lot of people here who are very upset, and very angry, and very frustrated.

And when they hear politicians slap -- you know, thanking one another, it just, you know, it kind of cuts them the wrong way right now, because literally there was a body on the streets of this town yesterday being eaten by rats because this woman had been laying in the street for 48 hours. And there's not enough facilities to take her up.

Sunday, August 28, 2005

Poor Little Rapist?

This is very odd. A commentator at Denver's 5280 blog expresses sympathy for a rapist who has been categorized as a sex offender and got a big town meeting dedicated to informing the locals about his move out of jail and back into the community.

Wednesday, August 24, 2005

Fred Phelps has Made a New Religion?

One Guy's Take on the Westboro "God hates Figs" Baptist Church

Members of WBC generally avoid the name "Christian" when referring to themselves, preferring the mysterious term "Tachmonite." This apparently refers to a servant of King David's, but I'm not sure of the derivation or the intention.

The Tachmonites believe Phelps is "the last prophet," with the power to determine who will be damned and who will be saved. They themselves, as followers of Phelps, also have the power to condemn souls to hell. Most people are destined for hell, but "Good Samaritans" who help the Tachmonites (for example, police officers who prevent counter-protesters from assaulting them) may be offered an indeterminate "reward" for their good conduct. Apparently "sola fide" is not part of the Tachmonites' creed.

via Eve Tushnet

Phelps' acolytes paid a visit to my parish last Easter Sunday, so I did a bit of slumming at their website. There are definitely remnants of old Reformation-Era doctrines, such as a commitment to Calvinistic predestination, but I didn't notice the wackier theology described here. Not that it would be incredibly surprising.

Saturday, August 20, 2005

Renaissance-Era Catholic Ban on Dissection Overstated?

The Catholic Encyclopedia's article on Anatomy claims the ban on dissection was hardly so strict as some have alleged:

It is very commonly accepted that there was an interruption in the development of anatomical knowledge about the beginning of the fourteenth century because of a papal decree forbidding dissection. The statement that such a decree was promulgated is to be found in nearly every history of medicine published in English, and has been made much of in books on the supposed opposition of science and religion. There was no such decree, however, and the declaration that the development of anatomy was interfered with by the ecclesiastical authorities is founded on nothing more substantial than a misunderstanding of the purport of a decree of Pope Boniface VIII. In the year 1300 this Pope issued the Bull "De Sepulturis". The title of the Bull runs as follows: "Persons cutting up the bodies of the dead, barbarously cooking them in order that the bones being separated from the flesh may be carried for burial into their own countries are by the very fact excommunicated." The only possible explanation of the misunderstanding that the Bull forbade dissection is that some one read only the first part of the title and considered that as one of the methods of preparing bones for study in anatomy was by boiling them in order to be able to remove the flesh from them easily, that this decree forbade such practices thereafter.


A bit of lazy googling couldn't confirm this, but the only sites I read arguing otherwise were relying on those bad nineteenth-century "war between science and religion" historiographies.

Tuesday, August 09, 2005

In Public, There is no Beer

via Dappled Things, an argument for allowing supervised underage drinking parties. This paragraph particularly caught my eye:

Not only do such uncompromising approaches do little to make our roads safer, they often make them worse. The data don't lie. High school kids drink, particularly during prom season. We might not be comfortable with that, but it's going to happen. It always has. The question, then, is do we want them drinking in their cars, in parking lots, in vacant lots and in rented motel rooms? Or do we want them drinking at parties with adult supervision, where they're denied access to the roads once they enter?


Oddly enough, this is one of the arguments also used to justify enabling teenage rutting. I think a better argument for supervised drinking must describe the merits of drinking itself. Rather than focus on avoiding all the illnesses and deaths that can accompany overconsumption of spirited beverages, focus on conviviality and building concord among the generations. Typical of late Liberalism, we are only allowed to appeal to the relatively minor public goods of health and safety rather than the good life. And I'd bet "joys of drinking" lectures beat "safe sex" ones anyday.

As for drunk driving concerns, nobody seems conscious that such problems are exacerbated by the strictures of zoning regulations. In much of suburbia, there is no such thing as a neighborhood bar or, better, a pub. To be manipulative, how many people must die before we can walk home drunk?

Monday, August 08, 2005

Hank Hill has a News Flash for LifeTeen Groupies

via the tNP forums:
"Can't you see you're not making Christianity better, you're just making rock n' roll worse."

Very sharp take on the jesus market. Somewhat fortunately, I managed to avoid my parish's youth group during my high school years, and thus all the transparent and shallow gimmickry.



One friend who has LifeTeen Groupie friends has commented that the advertising industry spends billions to nail down exactly what buttons to push to get people to commit their dollars to their clients' products. Shoestring Budget youth ministry shouldn't even try to compete in that area. Not that that stops them. Jesus is not our Ad Executive, though often we would like him to be.

Friday, August 05, 2005

Art, She is Not Dead

Back in the late eighties I saw my first computer-generated cartoon. A field trip to the National Renewable Energy Labs, (or was it the National Center for Atmospheric Research?) up near Boulder ended with our class sitting in a small theater watching an exquisitely-crafted CGI cartoon about a love story between a bird and a fish who lived with all their fellows in a large sphere. As any kid would be, I was utterly entranced with the short piece. A few years later, I made a ray-traced picture for a chess club flyer using good old POV-ray, a small freeware program. It looked great, especially since somebody else had built the framework for the chess piece models.

Of course, I quickly forgot about POV, and it never entered my mind until I discovered the POV Hall of Fame and CGTalk.com's Choice Gallery. Sci-fi, fantasy, M.C. Escher, and Terry Gilliam's films are obvious influences. But at the moment what particularly strikes me about the medium is its many artists' dedication to realism--even if it is "magical" realism. Supposedly realism in painting declined with the invention of the photographic camera. But now that CGI artists are attempting to make nearly photorealistic portrayals of the images in their mind, it looks like the style might be up for renewal.

In the better art galleries, one comes across students planted in front of some finely-made painting with an easel and a pallette, hoping to learn the techniques of the masters. Likewise, some CG artists try to recreate classic works. There is an admirable attempt at remaking Jan Vermeer's Girl with a Pearl Earring, and one talented artist has made a stunning copy of Michaelangelo's Pieta.

A few "magical realist" pieces that caught my eye are Medieval Airport and one called Family, a snapshot of life amid a sea of pipes and machinery.

But perhaps the saddest artwork I have found in this medium is Innocent Shadow, depicting one small space in Nagasaki a few years after the atomic bombing.

Thursday, August 04, 2005

A New Era Dawning?

Via Rachel Jurado, I just discovered this plot point in Tom Wolfe's I am Charlotte Simmons:

The novel begins with frat boy Hoyt Thorpe’s discovery of a sexual encounter between a Republican governor and presidential contender (and Dupont alumnus) and a Dupont co-ed. This episode goes unnoticed by the national media, but it and the ethical complications that grow out of it provide the novel’s backdrop—the absence of absolute moral standards.

At his commencement speech the day after having sex with the co-ed, the governor tells the students, “Over the next hundred years, new sets of values will inevitably replace the skeletons of the old, and it will be up to you to define them.”


Wolfe sure has his finger on the pulse here. Putting such words in the mouth of a Democrat would be too cliched, ignoring the New Men of the GOP.

Tuesday, August 02, 2005

Science and Islamic Pseudohistory!

The American Association for the Advancement of Science has apparently published a long piece claiming the Christian West got many, many philosophical goodies from Muslim philosophers. This is not quite the case, as
Jonathan David Carson
notes.

The historian Christopher Dawson did perceive some Averroism in the thought of certain Italian scientists, even Leonardo da Vinci, as I recall. It's recorded somewhere in my dead tree notebooks. However, Averroism itself, like the Straussian school, deprecates religious belief in favor of purely philosophical life and inquiry.

Friday, July 29, 2005

On "Almost Comically Vile" Transhumanism

"Obviously one is dealing here with a sensibility formed more by comic books than by serious thought."

"Of course, there was always a certain oafish audacity in Fletcher’s degenerate driveling about “morons” and “defectives,” given that there is good cause to suspect, from a purely utilitarian vantage, that academic ethicists—especially those like Fletcher, who are notoriously mediocre thinkers, possessed of small culture, no discernible speculative gifts, no records of substantive philosophical achievement, and execrable prose styles—constitute perhaps the single most useless element in society."

"Decisions regarding who should or should not live can, by definition, be made only by those who believe such decisions should be made; and therein lies the horror that nothing can ever exorcise from the ideology behind human bioengineering."

"There is, as it happens, nothing inherently wicked in the desire to become a god, at least not from the perspective of Christian tradition; and I would even say that if there is one element of the transhumanist creed that is not wholly contemptible—one isolated moment of innocence, however fleeting and imperfect—it is the earnestness with which it gives expression to this perfectly natural longing. Theologically speaking, the proper destiny of human beings is to be “glorified”—or “divinized”—in Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit, to become “partakers of the divine nature” (II Peter 1:4), to be called “gods” (Psalm 82:6; John 10:34-36). This is the venerable doctrine of “theosis” or “deification,” the teaching that—to employ a lapidary formula of great antiquity—“God became man that man might become god”: that is to say, in assuming human nature in the incarnation, Christ opened the path to union with the divine nature for all persons."

-David B. Hart The Anti-theology of the Body

Thursday, July 28, 2005

Private Vice is, erm, Public Vice?

"..the more expensive the harbor is the less likely it is it will ever be built."
"What are you suggesting, that we exaggerate the cost?"
"My dear Narcissus, you have money in corn, I have money in corn, lots of people have money in corn. The more corn that can be landed in winter the lower the price will be. That worries me."
"That could be construed as a very selfish point of view."
"Are you saying there is less selfishness in wanting the price of corn to be low rather than high?"
"But there are more people who want it to be low!"
"Doesn't that add up to more selfishness rather than less?"
"That is sheer sophistry, I cannot argue with you."
"Well let's get the engineer's report, and I'm quite sure the costs will take care of philosophical considerations."
-Two Patricians, I, Claudius

Get your Hollywood Rumors Here!

But Scientology not only has a base in Hollywood, it has enjoyed powerful friends in Washington. For years, Scientology fought a battle with the IRS because the government would not recognize its claim to be a religion. The IRS finally granted Scientology its desired status under President Bill Clinton, the recipient of massive donations from Hollywood.

Now it gets more interesting: Clinton helped the Church of Scientology in return for John Travolta, a member of Scientology, softening up his portrayal of the Clinton character in Primary Colors! Clinton and Travolta cut a deal. Travolta agreed to go easy on Clinton in the movie Primary Colors and Clinton reportedly agreed to use his influence to get the German government to leave Scientology alone.

Cliff Kincaid, Tom Cruise Vs. Mel Gibson, Accuracy in Media


This would make a great story, but I doubt if there's any basis for this. For one, Travolta doesn't seem to have had much creative control of the project. But the ways of Washington and the ways of Hollywood are all mysteries to me.

Excuses for not Reading Latin Works Just Went Down by One

The complete works of Augustine in Latin are online! via The Old Oligarch

Wednesday, July 27, 2005

Where are the Staunch Church-State Separationists now?

At $21,000 for a 30-day stay, the University of Colorado's new addiction-recovery center likely will attract more lawyers, executives and doctors than working-class folks.

"We talk about spirituality, about a power greater than themselves. They begin not seeing the center of the universe as themselves." (Dr. Franklin Lisnow, CeDAR's executive director)

"Patients, not insurers, likely to pay for CU's addiction clinic"

Rocky Mtn News 7/27/05

Monday, July 25, 2005

Pope bet on his own election!

Irish Journalist has the story



Considering that betting on the papal election is punishable by excommunication, this could be fodder for people who want to ignore the last few years of Cardinal Ratzinger's tenure at the CDF. The odd radical trad might use this to justify their continuing disobedience, but fortunately all excommunications are automatically lifted for electors in a papal election.

On a related note, Father Joseph Komonchak has published an article titled The Church in Crisis. It seems flawed at points, and Jamie Blosser offers his take.

Academic Jargon Written as Personal Threats!

"I'll emanate your penumbra!"
"I'll shift your paradigm!"
"I'll immanentize your eschaton!"
"I'll raise your awareness!"
"I'll privilege your oppression!"
"I'll nuance your worldview!"
"I'll overthrow your status quo!
"I'll diversify your mindset!"
"I'll subvert your hierarchy!"
"I'll delegitimize your security!
"I'll marginalize your voice!"

Saturday, July 23, 2005

Every Sin a Misdirected Virtue

Eve Tushnet on problems in some "ex-gay" thought and rhetoric:

Jesus wept, people, read some daggone Evelyn Waugh why don't you! Read some Augustine. What on earth would make you think that sin never contains any seed of goodness, any element of love? St. Augustine thought precisely the opposite of that--that every sin was a virtue misdirected.
[...]
But then I noticed my other huge problem with the "ex-gay" form letter Jason describes: There's nothing to be loved. There's nothing beautiful to Whom the writer cleaves. There's only something horrible to be shunned. And while I have some personal sympathy for that perspective--the horror of sin is sometimes much easier for me to see than the beauty of Christ--it's a thoroughly crippled view of the Christian life.

I believe what the Catholic Church teaches not solely--not even, when I'm at my best, primarily--because the alternatives are ugly. Quite often the alternatives are attractive, insofar as they partake in a partial share of the goodness, love, and grace that God offers. I believe what the Catholic Church teaches because, when I'm at my best, I love Jesus Christ, I love God, and I can faintly discern the beauty, hope, and peace He wants for me.


Quite relevant to the Wilde quotation below.

In the Spirit of Localism

Just discovered a local political gossip and punditry weblog, Colorado Political News. It has comments, so I can inflict my views, whether wise or deranged, on people who live in my area.



Also, the Denver magazine 5280 also has a blog. I think I only touched their magazine once in my life. I'm under the impression it's for LoDo yuppies, but we'll see.

Friday, July 22, 2005

Quantum Agents versus Mechanistic Handpuppets

'Is there anything more boring than using Heisenberg's uncertainty principle
to try to prove free will?'

-Walker Percy, Lost in the Cosmos

Since my sophomore year in college, I haven't put much store in using contemporary physics theories to establish the freedom of the will. For one, I haven't the advanced knowledge necessary to speak with any authority on quantum physics. I've read Hawking's Brief History of Time, a few other articles written for laymen, and I've had a few basic physics classes. What's worse, it seems to be a major talking point for crappy new age inspirational works, one example being, I am told, the movie "What the Bleep do We Know?" So on the principle that better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and remove all doubt, I simply passed it by. Besides, I hadn't come across any explication of how quantum mechanics could be brought to bear on the question.

That is, until I came across QUANTUM PHYSICS IN NEUROSCIENCE AND PSYCHOLOGY: A NEUROPHYSICAL MODEL OF MIND/BRAIN INTERACTION.

By necessity, it's an interdisciplinary work written by a Berkeley physicist, a neurologist, and a neuropsychiatrist. The paper has been published in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, which hopefully means it has passed through a crucible of quality peer review.

I sure can't critique many of the arguments invoking the big names of twentieth century physics. However, my concern about this article is that it seems to believe that human influences on descriptions of the world actually shape the world itself. Perhaps this isn't a confusion, but a foundational discovery or assumption of the new physics, but when the authors write "Thus the choice made by the observer about how he or she will act at a macroscopic level has, at the practical level, a profound effect on the physical system being acting upon" I suspect they are blowing something out of all proportion. I can grant that some observations change the observed thing, but I haven't a clue how that works on a cosmic level. If somebody wants to explain to me how telescopic measurement of light a star put out 50,000 years ago affects the star today, please do.

The paper jibes with some recent findings on how mental habits can change even the physical structure of the brain. I believe those studies concentrated on Buddhist monks, and oddly enough the Buddhist virtue of mindfulness pops up in this paper. As soon as Buddhist writings were cited, I feared I had stumbled onto some crappy new age pseudophysics, but the Buddhist remarks were relevant and not dwelled upon.

Anyway, the authors claim that, in contradistinction to classical Newtonian physics, wherein the observer was simply one more part(or sum of parts) in a mechanical universe, contemporary physics incorporates the observer's "inner space:"

The core idea of classical physics was to describe the “world out there,” with no reference to “our thoughts in here.” But the core idea of quantum mechanics is to describe both our activities as knowledge-seeking and knowledge-acquiring agents, and also the knowledge that we thereby acquire. Thus quantum theory involves, basically, what is “in here,” not just what is “out there.”

This philosophical shift arises from the explicit recognition by quantum physicists that science is about what we can know. It is fine to have a beautiful and elegant mathematical theory about a really existing physical world out there that meets various intellectually satisfying criteria. But the essential demand of science is that the theoretical constructs be
tied to the experiences of the human scientists who devise ways of testing the theory, and of the human engineers and technicians who both participate in these tests, and eventually put the theory to work. Thus the structure of a proper physical theory must involve not only the part describing the behavior of the not-directly-experienced theoretically postulated entities, expressed in some appropriate symbolic language, but also a part describing the human experiences that are pertinent to these tests and applications, expressed in the language that we actually use to describe such experiences to ourselves and to each other. And the theory must specify the connection between these two differently described and differently conceived parts of scientific practice.


Happily, the writers do not follow the habit of so many armchair quantum mystics and leave "free will" a vague and cheery phrase. For the purposes of their paper, free choices are free "in the sense that they are not specified by the currently known laws of physics." This is because for the Copenhagen school of quantum physics, "the human experimenter is considered to stand outside the system to which the quantum laws are applied." (In this there is an echo of another Dane, Kierkegaard, who pointed out that the self is always a leftover of one's theory.) I suspect here the difficulties are passed over, which might lead a reader even more casual than I to believe their argument is more solid than it is. In one sense, this can be caricatured as the statement "our system presupposes it, therefore it must be true."

The paper also, alas, invokes the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle to support free will. as I read them, they hold that nobody will ever be able to completely capture the activity of the calcium ions bouncing between nerve endings, and so determinism is unprovable by scientific means. Obviously, the impossibility of proof for determinism isn't a positive proof for free will. I hope I have misread them here, but it seems they are going about proving human agency, and not human freedom. However, in their defense I believe that they aren't so much arguing for free will as a belief requiring full assent to the belief "this is real," as for a more pragmatic belief "this works." As the psychological section declares, "Quantum physics works better in neuropsychology than its classical approximation because it inserts knowable choices made by human agents into the dynamics in place of unknowable-in-principle microscopic variables." In addition, the paper makes a few predictions about "attention density," a concept I'm not going to touch, the measurements of which they claim should vindicate their position.

Supposedly, quantum mechanics doesn't apply to the atomic level at which the brain works. For what it's worth, the authors of this paper argue against it, claiming neurobiology can be described by "almost classical physics," but not classical physics simpliciter. I'll leave that evaluation to my scientific betters. Also of note, the article touches upon the Libet Experiment, which various popularizers presented as hard evidence for determinism.

Part of their conclusion is worth recording here:

Materialist ontology draws no support from contemporary physics, and is in fact contradicted by it. The notion that all physical behavior is explainable in principle solely in terms of a local mechanical process is a holdover from physical theories of an earlier era. It was rejected by the founders of quantum mechanics, who introduced crucially into the basic dynamical equations choices that are not determined by local mechanical processes, but are attributed rather to human agents.


Their last line reads: "A shift to this pragmatic approach that incorporates agent-based choices as primary empirical input variables may be as important to progress in neuroscience and psychology as it was to progress in atomic physics." In my eyes, an "agent" is not quite a person, but the concept is certainly better off than the marionette theory of the self.

A Decadent Speaks

"Much of my moral obliquity is due to the fact that my father would not allow me to become a Catholic. The artistic side of the Church and the fragrance of its teachings would have cured my degeneracies. I intend to be received before long"

-Oscar Wilde, via Wittingshire.

I went on a Wilde binge my first semester at college, courtesy of a Wilde anthology inherited from a great-uncle. Dorian Gray still haunts me, and I suspect it kept me out of a great deal of trouble. A re-read is certainly in order. He has been adopted by some libertines who neglect his regrets.

Monday, July 18, 2005

A Bon Mot for the Day

Self-mockery, like sound argument, is a prophylactic against bad criticism.

Mock-Irish Whiggery

A great tramping, barracking, bollocking man was our Father O'Pression. His writ ran the length and breadth, the highways and the byways, the up hill and the down dale of County Tooraloora. And to be sure, any of us boys at Saint Miseryguts had only to whisper a hint of a glimmer of a fancy of what we all wanted to do to witty, pretty Kitty McMahon behind Finnegan's cowshed, when then, as sudden as the rains that fell from the shimmering, slatey-grey clouds above, he would appear before us, as tall and as terrible as old Finn MacCool himself, stinking of the bacon sandwiches he stuffed in his soutane, of the Jameson's he swigged from a battered pewter flask and of the lack of the deodorant he damned as a wicked Protestant innovation, the wrath of a thousand Dies Iraes in his eyes, etc etc.

via Kevin Michael Grace

Thursday, July 14, 2005

Straight from a Doc Percy novel

THE HEDONISTIC IMPERATIVE
This manifesto outlines a strategy to eradicate suffering in all sentient life. The abolitionist project is ambitious, implausible, but technically feasible. It is defended here on ethical utilitarian grounds. Genetic engineering and nanotechnology allow Homo sapiens to discard the legacy-wetware of our evolutionary past. Our post-human successors will rewrite the vertebrate genome, redesign the global ecosystem, and abolish suffering throughout the living world.

Wednesday, July 13, 2005

Another Banal Atrocity in an Age Full of Atrocities

George Neumayr tries to put together the numbers on Eugenic Abortion



Addendum 7/18: DarwinCatholic on Parents who Don't Abort Down's Syndrome Kids

A Time to Laugh.... At Richard Dawkins!

From a BBC article:

Each species, in fact, has a different "reality". They work with different "software" to make them feel comfortable, he suggested.

Because different species live in different models of the world, there was a discomfiting variety of real worlds, he suggested.

[...]

He concluded with the thought that if he could re-engineer his brain in any way he would make himself a genius mathematician.

He would also want to time travel to when dinosaurs roamed the Earth.


That, and he'd like a genetically-engineered talking pony too.

I don't believe I've referenced Stephen M. Barr's delightful review of Dawkins' last book. Here's my favorite paragraph:

One encounters in A Devil’s Chaplain at least three Dawkinses: there is Dawkins the Humanist, Dawkins the Reasoner, and Dawkins the Darwinist. Each sits on a different branch, sawing away at the branches on which the others sit. Dawkins the Humanist preaches, inveighs, denounces; he bristles with moral indignation. Dawkins the Darwinist tells him, however, that his humanism is speciesist vanity, his moral standards arbitrary, and his indignation empty. Dawkins the Humanist rebels, proclaiming himself (in human affairs) passionately anti-Darwinian. Dawkins the Reasoner joins the rebellion, declaring that our minds allow us to transcend our genetic inheritance. Dawkins the Darwinist answers with lethal effect that our brains “were only designed to understand the mundane details of how to survive in the stone-age African savannah.”

Thursday, July 07, 2005

I just learned of the Speigel interview with African economist James Shikwati, noticing how much aid money is counterproductive. I'll skimp on organizing this post just to pull out a few gems:

Malaria is just as much of a problem[as AIDS], but people rarely talk about that.


Because for one reason the most effective anti-mosquito efforts used DDT, which is anathema to the environmentalists. I'm surprised he thinks AIDS is a political disease on his own continent.

Why do we get these mountains of clothes? No one is freezing here.
[...]


Jobs with foreign aid organizations are, of course, quite popular, and they can be very selective in choosing the best people. When an aid organization needs a driver, dozens apply for the job. And because it's unacceptable that the aid worker's chauffeur only speaks his own tribal language, an applicant is needed who also speaks English fluently -- and, ideally, one who is also well mannered. So you end up with some African biochemist driving an aid worker around, distributing European food, and forcing local farmers out of their jobs. That's just crazy!


This is pretty funny. Pity such absurdity has a negative impact on so many people.



I've wondered if aid could be better spent in setting up small credit unions free of corruption to make business loans and provide better funding sources for African economic renewal. But the poster proxy_user on FreeRepublic takes a cynical view: "But Mr.Shikwati! The Europeans are not as dumb as you think. They have their hands full competing with China and India. They certainly don't want to have to compete with Africa too, and for a very small price they are able to dodge that problem."

Wednesday, July 06, 2005

The Future Belongs to Whom?

In The New Atlantis Charles T. Rubin has written a wise essay, titled Daedalus and Icarus Revisited, reflecting on the debate between Haldane and Russell about science, ethics, and progress. One paragraph:

Above all, the very thinness of any notion of progress that survives the Haldane-Russell debate—little more than the fact of accumulation of knowledge and a vague hope that things might turn out well in light of unspecified yet grand civilizational projects—helps to explain the widespread belief that any effort to restrain science on the basis of ethics represents a threat to “scientific progress.” To see this as simply a result of the self-interest of scientists is to do them an injustice. Like Haldane, most scientists are probably unaware of how the belief that morality must adjust to scientific and technological change amounts to saying that might makes right. The sense of threat is partly due to the poverty of thought on the subject, and perhaps the narrow education that is required for making measurable scientific achievements. For restraint doubtless would slow accumulation, and (from this point of view) can only represent the triumph of fear over hope. But what is to be said for accumulation when Russell and Haldane have done with it? It serves either the power of the conventionally powerful or the power of the scientists.

Wednesday, June 29, 2005

Death to Theory! Long Live Eloquence!

When a colleague of mine returned from an MLA convention in Toronto around that time, he told a story that nicely illustrated the trend. One afternoon he hopped on a shuttle bus and sat down next to a young scholar who told him she’d just returned from a panel. He replied that he’d just returned from France, where he’d been studying for a semester.
“What are they talking about?” she asked.

“Hmm?”

“Is there any new theory?”

“Yeah, in a way,” he answered. “It’s called ‘erudition.’”

“What’s that?” she wondered.

“Well, you read and read, and you get your languages, and you go into politics, religion, law, contemporary events, and just about everything else.” (He’s a 16th-century French literature scholar who comes alive in archives.)

She was puzzled. “But what’s the theory?”

“To be honest, there isn’t any theory,” he said.

“That’s impossible.” He shrugged. “Okay, then, give me the names, the people heading it.”

“There aren’t any names. Nobody’s heading it.”

A trivial exchange, yes, but it signals the professional meaning and moral barrenness Theory accrued in the Nineties. The more popular Theory became, the less it inspired deep commitments among searching minds. The more Theory became enshrined in anthologies ordered semester after semester, the more it became a token of professional wisdom. The only energy Theory sustained during those years issued from a non-philosophical source: the race/gender/sexuality/anti-imperialism/anti-bourgeois resentments tapped by various critics giving different objects of oppression theoretical standing.


Theory's Empire

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

Here's to you, Mr. Detweiler

I have just discovered the website of one of my best Junior High school teachers, Ken Detweiler. He was a Civil War reenactor and often had a bunch of his friends come in character, to the point where they would ask what a savage (the long-haired Mexican-Indian kid) was doing in school with whites. Boy was that a lawsuit waiting to happen!



He'd also have some students shoot a recreated Civil War-era cannon, with actual gunpowder. Looks like he's discovered even more fun stuff for his students:

Probably my biggest project was bringing WWII armor to the school several years ago. We gave every student a ride on an armored half-track, and winners of an essay contest earned a trip in a sixteen ton WWII Stuart tank! (They tell me that there are only three such tanks left in America that are still used regularly for public demonstrations. )

In 2000, I was able to train 240 students from Oberon as a nine-company Civil War battalion in order to recreate the famous charge of the 1st Texas Regiment at Antietam.

My latest project is working on designing two big field trips. I organized two huge out of state field trips last year - one to New Mexico and one to Gettysburg. I can hardly wait to go back again!


Sad to see he has only won a single teacher of the year award, though he's been nominated for many others.

Monday, June 27, 2005

For Future Reference

Pontifications has posted the interesting essay “I am in the Church” by Jean Danielou, S.J. It seems to have been written in the '70s.

Thursday, June 23, 2005

"By a faction, I understand a number of citizens, whether amounting to a majority or a minority of the whole, who are united and actuated by some common impulse of passion, or of interest, adversed to the rights of other citizens, or to the permanent and aggregate interests of the community."

-James Madison, Federalist 10

The editors needed to grab readers’ attention without getting some so mad they cancelled their subscriptions. Kaiser and Stanley yearned to win awards with tough reporting but without alienating the community.

“We’re losing touch with our readers,” Senior Editor Gary Krentz would say, suggesting that the coverage of some issue had gone too far in one direction.

In the Belly of the Beast (via The Japery)


In politics, too, one strives to get attention and support alongside the goal of alienating as few people as possible. Here, we have support for a thesis that both political parties and the mainstream media comprise a single faction.

Addendum 8/04:

Richard Posner in the NYTimes sees something similar, albeit without disapproving or bringing faction into it:

To see what difference the elimination of a communications bottleneck can make, consider a town that before the advent of television or even radio had just two newspapers because economies of scale made it impossible for a newspaper with a small circulation to break even. Each of the two, to increase its advertising revenues, would try to maximize circulation by pitching its news to the median reader, for that reader would not be attracted to a newspaper that flaunted extreme political views. There would be the same tendency to political convergence that is characteristic of two-party political systems, and for the same reason - attracting the least committed is the key to obtaining a majority.

One of the two newspapers would probably be liberal and have a loyal readership of liberal readers, and the other conservative and have a loyal conservative readership. That would leave a middle range. To snag readers in that range, the liberal newspaper could not afford to be too liberal or the conservative one too conservative. The former would strive to be just liberal enough to hold its liberal readers, and the latter just conservative enough to hold its conservative readers. If either moved too close to its political extreme, it would lose readers in the middle without gaining readers from the extreme, since it had them already.


He does, however, incorporate the Press into the system for moderating the effects of factionalism:
Still, because there is a market demand for correcting the errors and ferreting out the misdeeds of one's enemies, the media exercise an important oversight function, creating accountability and deterring wrongdoing. That, rather than educating the public about the deep issues, is their great social mission. It shows how a market produces a social good as an unintended byproduct of self-interested behavior.

Wednesday, June 22, 2005

Something to look for:

Are the people who say such things as "If you don't like it, change the channel" often the same people who berate certain parents for "isolating their children from the real world"?

One Hymn that Belongs in Contemporary Parishes

Faith of our fathers, living still,
In spite of dungeon, fire and sword;
O how our hearts beat high with joy
Whenever we hear that glorious Word!

Refrain

Faith of our fathers, holy faith!
We will be true to thee till death.

Faith of our fathers, we will strive
To win all nations unto Thee;
And through the truth that comes from God,
We all shall then be truly free.

Refrain

Faith of our fathers, Mary’s prayers
Shall win our country back to Thee;
And through the truth that comes from God,
England shall then indeed be free.


The third stanza was changed in Protestant hymnals to read:

Faith of our fathers, we will love
Both friend and foe in all our strife;
And preach Thee, too, as love knows how
By kindly words and virtuous life.


It seems this modified version was sung at FDR's funeral. Changing "England" to "Our Land" would work quite well in an American context, I think.

Friday, June 17, 2005

Sound of Music: EVIL!!!!

For the Schism makes you Stupid file:
November 7, 1997

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

As the Christmas season comes round again, no doubt many Catholic households, especially but not only in the U.S.A., will be preparing to watch, on public television or on video-tape,

The Sound of Music. This Hollywood film has repeatedly been the object of critical remarks in this letter. If readers have wondered why, let it now for the season be explained at length.

Read More


This is by Richard Williamson, one of the bishops leading the schismatic Priestly Society of St. Pius X. Wizard of Oz, watch out!

Wednesday, June 15, 2005

Jesus broke my Worldview!

Balthasar, as it happens, was a close friend and neighbor of Barth in Basel, and the influence of the latter on the former was deep and long-lasting (Balthasar’s influence on Barth, however, was less notable). What both had in common was an insistence that the Bible be taken on its own terms, even if both accepted as well the results of historical criticism (provided they were reliable). For both as well, accepting the Bible on its own terms meant that it would be impossible, pace Schleiermacher and Rahner, to subsume the figure of Jesus into some more overarching framework. In other words, Jesus’ claim to be “the Way, the Truth, and the Life” (John 14:6) must be taken on its own terms, quite independent of the historical process by which that claim came to be embedded in the Fourth Gospel and not in the others. And if that claim is taken on its own terms, it shows that Jesus was not merely a teacher who pointed to the way but was, in himself, in his own person, the Way itself.

But to any worldview whatever, such a claim, no matter how mediated, must lead to outrage. For a claim to be the Way, the Truth, the Life means at core that one whitecap atop a wave claims to be not only the sea and the seabed but the generating matrix of the world as well (“Before Abraham was, I am”). Moreover, that claim is so preposterous that it can only be validated by God himself in the resurrection. Thus the three together – Claim, Death, and Resurrection – form a triadic pattern (Gestalt, one of Balthasar’s favorite words) that is the indissoluble core of the Christian proclamation.

Edward T. Oakes, Article "Christology" in the forthcoming Blackwell Companion to Catholicism


Father Oakes sent me this article, along with an excellent review of From Darwin to Hitler coming up in First Things.

Tuesday, June 14, 2005

Not-So-Quizzical Results

Don't think I posted an Internet Quiz before, but here's one:

Roman Catholic

100%

Neo orthodox

79%

Evangelical Holiness/Wesleyan

71%

Emergent/Postmodern

68%

Charismatic/Pentecostal

54%

Reformed Evangelical

32%

Classical Liberal

21%

Fundamentalist

18%

Modern Liberal

11%

What's your theological worldview?
created with QuizFarm.com


I don't think there is such a thing as a Christian Worldview, though it's interesting to see how little I have in common with answers attributed to both Fundamentalism and Liberalism.

The Dead Have Been Seen Alive


Hallaig
by Sorley Maclean

`Time, the deer is in the Wood of Hallaig.'

The window is nailed and boarded
through which I saw the West
and my love is at the Burn of Hallaig,
a birch tree, and she has always been

between Inver and Milk Hollow,
here and there about Baile-chuirn:
she is a birch, a hazel,
a straight slender young rowan.

In Screapadal of my people,
where Norman and Big Hector were,
their daughters and their sons are a wood
going up beside the stream.

Proud tonight the pine cocks crowing
on the top of Cnoc an Ra
straight their backs in the moonlight--
they are not the wood I love.

I will wait for the birch wood
until it comes up by the Cairn,
until the whole ridge from Beinn na Lice
will be under its shade.

If it does not, I will go down to Hallaig,
to the sabbath of the dead,
where the people are frequenting,
every single generation gone.

They are still in Hallaig,
Macleans and MacLeods,
all who were there in the time of MacGille Chaluim:
the dead have been seen alive--

the men lying on the green
at the end of every house that was,
the girls a wood of birches,
straight their backs, bent their heads.

Between the Leac and Fearns
the road is under wild moss
and the girls in silent bands
go to Clachan as in the beginning.

And return from Clachan,
from Suisnish and the land of the living;
each one young and light-stepping,
without the heartbreak of the tale.

From the Burn of Fearns to the raised beach
that is clear in the mystery of the hills,
there is only the congregation of the girls
keeping up the endless walk,

coming back to Hallaig in the evening,
in the dumb living twilight,
filling the steep slopes,
their laughter in my ears a mist,

and their beauty a film on my heart
before the dimness comes on the kyles,
and when the sun goes down behind Dun Cana
a vehement bullet will come from the gun of Love;

and will strike the deer that goes dizzily,
sniffing at the grass-grown ruined homes;
his eye will freeze in the wood;
his blood will not be traced while I live.


I first heard this poem on the CD Bothy Culture by Martyn Bennett. Bennett overlaid the voice of MacLean reading his own English translation on an electronic instrumental riff.

Little did I realize that this poem was about the Highland Clearances!

The poem was incorporated into Peter Maxwell-Davies' opera The Jacobite Rising. I'll have to look him up. It seems he wrote Le Jongleur de Notre Dame, which was mentioned here some time back in a snipe at an article promoting a local performance.

What is Wrong with Proselytizing for the American Way of Life

For Illich, ministry to Puerto Ricans required a complete surrender of one’s own cultural values. He understood this surrender in explicitly Christian terms, equating it with the surrender of the will that precedes the reception of grace in traditional Christian theology. Although he was familiar with modern social theory, Illich nonetheless understood this surrender of cultural assumptions not in terms of objectivity or tolerance, but as “a beatitude of cultural poverty.” Illich spent vacations in Puerto Rico, walking and hitchhiking across the country, performing priestly duties and soaking up the peasant culture of the people; he became convinced that the future vitality of Puerto Rican Catholicism depended on the maintenance of Puerto Rican cultural traditions. One commentator on Illich has claimed that “if he had had his way he would have totally transferred the church of the campesinos, with its unpunctuality, its semi-pagan rituals, its great community feast days, to the streets of New York.” The appeal to tradition provided Illich with a language through which to subvert Spellman’s Americanization goals without appearing subversive.

Carnival in New York in tNP


In all our zeal for spreading democracy and freedom, there is no death to self and death to the world before the preaching of the "good news" of America and her saving power which is supposed to rescue others from tyranny and poverty.